Raz Sauber Podcast
Home › Israel · Arab citizens · Politics
Israel · Arab citizens · Politics

Why Don't Arab Parties in Israel Call Hamas a Terrorist Organization?

Every Arab-Israeli politician gets the same demand: condemn Hamas. Most condemn October 7th, but few will use the words "terrorist organization." Dr. Thaer Abu Ras of the Van Leer Institute explains the reasoning on the Raz Sauber Podcast, and host Raz Sauber pushes back.

The short answer

  • Condemning the October 7th attack is easy for Arab citizens of Israel, Abu Ras says: the victims were their fellow citizens.
  • Labeling Hamas a "terrorist organization" is different. To many Arab citizens it means adopting one side's narrative of the whole conflict.
  • He compares it to asking Israeli Jews who criticize the Gaza war to call the IDF a terrorist organization. They won't, even if they criticize specific actions.
  • Host Raz Sauber rejects the comparison: the IDF has no charter calling to wipe out Palestinians, and the gap between the two is "an understatement."
  • Abu Ras expects Ra'am leader Mansour Abbas to say the words if they ever become the price of political influence, as he did when he recognized Israel as a Jewish state.

"Condemn Hamas": the demand every Arab politician hears

According to Abu Ras, Mansour Abbas, leader of the Islamist party Ra'am, avoids the conflict when he speaks Hebrew so he doesn't hand ammunition to the right. In Arabic he can't avoid it, and the question keeps coming back: why won't you condemn Hamas? Abbas will not support Hamas, Abu Ras says, but he won't condemn it either, because for the Arab public the issue is "more complicated."

Sauber wasn't convinced. "You listen to them," he said, "and you see them squirming in Hebrew too."

October 7th versus "terrorist organization"

Abu Ras separates condemning the attack from labeling the organization.

"Look, it's much easier to condemn October 7th, because there is no one who would agree with what happened on October 7th in Arab society in Israel, I mean, because we are citizens of the state, and those who were harmed are citizens of the state we live in." "תראה הרבה יותר קל לגנות את השביעי באוקטובר כי אין מישהו שיסכים למה שקרה בשביעי באוקטובר בחברה הערבית בישראל..."
Dr. Thaer Abu Ras · 30:53
"Arabs in Israel definitely think that Hamas commits acts of terror, but they don't look at it as a terrorist organization in the classic sense of the word." "הערבים בישראל חושבים בהחלט שחמאס עושה מעשה טרור אבל הם לא מסתכלים עליו בתור ארגון טרור במונח הקלאסי של המילה"
Dr. Thaer Abu Ras · 32:24

In his account, the reason is narrative. Many Arab citizens see the situation in Gaza as partly Israel's responsibility. He cites the 2005 disengagement, the blockade and years of "conflict management," and claims Israel deliberately strengthened Hamas at the expense of the Palestinian Authority. He also notes that Arab citizens followed the war mostly on Al Jazeera rather than on Israeli channels, and saw a different picture.

The comparison he calls "provocative"

Abu Ras offers an analogy aimed at Jewish listeners, and says himself that it is provocative.

"There are a lot of decent Jews who would agree that what Israel did in Gaza is not a legitimate war of defense, yes, and that crimes were committed deliberately inside the Gaza Strip, but go and tell those same people, 'Say that the IDF is a terrorist organization,' and they'll pull back for a moment." "יש המון יהודים הגונים שיסכימו שמה שישראל עשתה בעזה הוא לא מלחמת הגנה לגיטימית... אבל תבוא ותגיד לאותם אנשים תגידו שצה"ל הוא ארגון טרור אז הם ייקחו ככה חזרה רגע"
Dr. Thaer Abu Ras · 31:21
"Because you are, after all, part of a certain community, part of a certain narrative, and you feel that you are conceding to the other side; as long as he doesn't concede, you're a kind of sucker." "כי אתה בסך הכל חלק מקהילה מסוימת חלק מנרטיב מסוים ואתה מרגיש שאתה מוותר לצד השני כל עוד הוא לא מוותר אתה סוג של פראייר כזה"
Dr. Thaer Abu Ras · 32:12

The host pushes back

Sauber rejected the symmetry outright.

"Even if war crimes were committed in Gaza, the IDF, by definition, doesn't have, or didn't have, in its charter 'let's wipe out all the Palestinians.'" "גם אם נעשו פשעי מלחמה בעזה צה"ל by definition אין לו או לא היה לו בצ'רטר בוא נחסל את כל הפלסטינים"
Raz Sauber, host · 33:16

He then turned the question back to politics: if Mansour Abbas wants budgets and influence, why walk into the trap?

"Why do you fall into this trap? Say: yes, Hamas is a terrorist organization. What, didn't you see what they did on October 7th? Obviously it's a terrorist organization." "למה אתה נופל למלכודת הזאת תגיד כן זה ארגון טרור מה לא ראיתם מה הם עשו בשבעה באוקטובר ברור שזה ארגון טרור."
Raz Sauber, host · 33:48

Would Mansour Abbas ever say it?

Abu Ras thinks he would, if it became a condition.

"Mansour Abbas specifically, I think that in the end, if it becomes a condition, he'll find a way to say it, just as he found a way to recognize Israel as a Jewish state." "מנסור עבאס ספציפית אני חושב שבסופו של דבר אם זה יהיה תנאי הוא ימצא דרך להגיד את זה כמו שהוא מצא דרך להכיר בישראל כמדינה יהודית"
Dr. Thaer Abu Ras · 33:57

Later in the episode he places this inside his broader idea of "incomplete citizenship." Ra'am, he argues, doesn't give up on policy. It gives up on narrative.

"So what they give up is on the narrative level: recognizing Israel as a Jewish state, calling Hamas a terrorist organization, things like that, which are uncomfortable for them, but they are willing to swallow these frogs for the sake of the bigger goal." "אז מה שהם מוותרים עליו זה ברמה הנרטיבית הכרה בישראל כמדינה יהודית לקרוא לחמאס ארגון טרור... אבל הם מוכנים לבלוע את הצפרדעים הללו למען המטרה היותר גדולה."

"Swallowing frogs" is a Hebrew idiom for accepting something unpleasant.

Context for readers outside Israel

Mansour Abbas
Leader of Ra'am. In June 2021 his party joined the Bennett–Lapid coalition, the first time an independent Arab party sat in an Israeli government. Abu Ras describes him as deeply pragmatic and says Netanyahu was the first to meet and legitimize him publicly.
Ra'am (United Arab List)
The party of the southern, more moderate branch of the Islamic Movement in Israel. Its core base is Bedouin communities in the Negev. Abu Ras compares its approach to working inside the system rather than against it.
The Joint List
An alliance of Hadash (left, communist roots, two-state), Balad (Palestinian nationalist, "a state of all its citizens") and Ta'al (Ahmad Tibi's party). Today it supports governments from the outside rather than joining them.
Arab citizens of Israel
About a fifth of Israel's citizens. Many identify as Palestinian and Israeli at the same time, a theme Abu Ras discusses later in the episode.

Frequently asked questions

Do Arab parties in Israel condemn the October 7th attack?

According to Dr. Thaer Abu Ras, condemning the attack itself is not the issue: Arab citizens see the victims as their fellow citizens. The dispute is over labeling Hamas as a whole a "terrorist organization."

Why won't they call Hamas a terrorist organization?

Abu Ras says the label is seen as adopting one side's narrative of the conflict. He compares it to Israeli Jews who criticize the Gaza war but refuse to call the IDF a terrorist organization. Host Raz Sauber rejects that comparison.

Who is Mansour Abbas?

The leader of Ra'am, the Islamist party that joined Israel's governing coalition in 2021. Abu Ras expects that he would use the term if it became a condition for political influence.

Is the episode available in English?

The episode is in Hebrew. YouTube offers an English auto-dubbed audio track: open the player settings and choose Audio track → English.

Episode chapters

  1. 1:19What caused the historic Arab voter turnout
  2. 10:13Crime: the top issue for the Arab public
  3. 13:21Ra'am versus the Joint List
  4. 20:22What Mansour Abbas really wants
  5. 27:50What is said in Arabic and what in Hebrew
  6. 30:19Why not call Hamas a terrorist organization
  7. 46:36Palestinian and Israeli at the same time
  8. 1:02:12How Netanyahu legitimized Mansour Abbas
  9. 1:06:27"Incomplete citizenship": what Ra'am gives up

Quotes are faithful translations of what was said in Hebrew, with the original under each one. Claims about the Gaza war and Israeli policy are the speakers' own views, presented as they were said.

Watch the full conversation

76 minutes on Arab voters, Ra'am and the Joint List, identity, the flag and the anthem, and how close Netanyahu and Mansour Abbas came to a deal.

Watch on YouTube, Raz Sauber Podcast (English audio track available)

Produced by Sauber Media.